It seems that many of you would like a refresher on lie vs. lay. We remember our teachers telling us that the words are easily confused, and we worry that we're doing it wrong, so instead of saying something like "lay the book over there," we'll use an entirely different word: "set the book over there."
The verbs "lie" and "lay" (in present tense) actually have different meanings. "Lie" is a physical action that humans and other living beings take for themselves, as in "I don't feel well; I am going to lie down for a bit."
"Lay" is the word we use for nonliving objects: "I need to lay this heavy box down!"
The problem is that "lie" uses "lay" as its past tense! "After I lay down for a bit, I felt a lot better!"
Ugh!
To help things out a bit, I'm going to explain "transitive" and "intransitive" verbs. One of the worst parts of grammar, in my opinion, is all of these "big" words that are used to describe the concepts. Whip out words like "subordinate" or "participle" or "transitive" and watch eyes glaze over!
A transitive verb takes an object. For instance, think about a verb like "gave". Whenever we use it, we want to know what was given, right?
"My friend gave _________________."
The noun that goes in the blank is something called a direct object. The terminology isn't super important right now.
Some verbs, though, are either intransitive or can be used as both. Let's use "moves" for this example."
"Steve moves quickly."
There is nothing that Steve moves in this case.
Going back to lie vs. lay, lie is an intransitive verb, because the subject is doing the lying himself.
"I need to lie down."
But with lay, there is an object involved. If I lay something down, I need to know what that object is. I can't just say, "I lay down." What did I lay down?
Here are the conjugations for lie for the first person:
Present: I lie down when I am tired.
Past: I lay down when I was tired.
Past Participle: I have lain down for many naps.
Present Participle: I am laying down right now!
Here are the conjugations for lay for the first person:
Present: I lay my keys on the counter. (Notice the object is "keys" in this sentence.)
Past: I laid my wallet nearby. (Object is "wallet".)
Past Participle: I have laid several acres of mulch. (Object is "acres".)
Present Participle: Don't let me forget; I am laying the needle here. (Object is "needle".)
Does that help? When you're trying to decide which to use, just think about whether you are using an object or referring to yourself. If you've got an object in mind, go for a conjugation of lay; if it's you that is going to become horizontal, use a conjugation of "lie."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

9 comments:
Wow great explanation! The best I've ever seen actually. I think I may have gotten it now... (but I'll keep the site as reference for sure) But honnestly, the last one about the clauses, phew way over my head. I've always been stumped by that.
Can anyone be decent at writing without knowing why or how they write well ? (Like can I use suboordinate clauses or whatever, correctly, without knowing that I am? lol)
Thanks for that one, Heather! My problem has been the past tenses, knowing whether it's lay or laid.
Nancy, I think you can get it right and not know why. I think my english sentences are correct most of the time, but I'm completely clueless about grammar terms. As in, I've heard of subordinate clauses etc. before, but couldn't remember what they were, yet I've been using them and apparantly don't make so many mistakes that people are constantly correcting myself. It's the same with german for me, people ask me if I could teach them but my problem is that I can tell you how a sentence is supposed to be, but I can't tell you *why* that is. Same in english, with a few more mistakes.
And that was supposed to say "constantly correcting me". :-)
Confusing matters further, we have "Like a bridge over troubled water / I will lay me down," in which the speaker intends to be horizontal and uses "lay" correctly (albeit in its archaic, reflexive form).
I'm with Miika. Writing is my CAREER and I still don't fully grasp parts of speech, etc. Sometimes my boss asks me WHY something he's written is incorrect. I know it has something to do with a misplaced modifier or a dangling participle, but I don't know what those actually are. So I just tell him "I don't know WHY it is wrong - it just is."
Yup. I was always tempted to teach it w/ puns.. IE
"Women lie in bed"
But, I needed a job mingling w/ runts.
But, on re-think.. any runt who +got+ that pun didn't need me harping on
lie=sit
lay=put
Syb
PS..
This is a paste from yr entry, likely a typo??
(paste)
Present Participle: I am laying down right now!
(end paste)
I am lying down right now. (I am sitting down right now)
+see previous comment+
Now I am off to the doctor's where I will likely be told"
"Lay (sic) down"
It's sooooooo atrociously misused that whenever a doctor or nurse asks me to lie back, I compliment him/her:)
Syb
Any updates in here soon? ;-)
Heather, can I ask you to clarify something for me?
When is it "Alex and I", "Alex and me", "me and him" etc...
I always hear people say "at Alex and I's apartment" and that sounds so horribly wrong to me, yet I'm not sure if it really is wrong or not.
I always thought that whatever sentence you make, if you leave just "me" or "I", then as long as that shortened sentence makes sense, you've got the right one (me or I). Is that really true? Or are there other helpful ways to remember whether it's me, I, him or he?
Thanks!
Post a Comment